My 5 Favorite Comic Artists of all time
Posted in Opinions, Rants, and Musings on November 28th, 2008I’ve been collecting comics since the mid 80’s, and even though these days I can’t afford new ones very often, they’re still an obsession of mine, not to mention inspiration, since I’ve been working on my own comic book series for the past few months. Great comics, of course, come about as the result of the melding of exceptional story and art, so this time around, I thought I would list my top five favorite comic artists of all time.
First up, Jim Lee. I got on Lee’s bandwagon during his run on Uncanny X-Men with writer Chris Claremont for Marvel right around 1990, which was also around the time I started getting into comics in a really big way, and Lee’s contributions during this period definitely played a big part in that. The linear clarity of the action sequences and the perfectly sculpted physiques of what I still consider to be one of the best X-Men teams (now I’d have a tough time telling you all the members, the roster has swelled to ridiculous proportions) had me eagerly anticipating every new issue, and when Lee and Claremont were tapped to be the creative team on the new X-Men comic, it was a dream come true for me, and I wasn’t disappointed with the results. The first twelve issues of that series, X-Men, I also consider some of the best I’ve ever read, the artwork stunning, and the writing every bit as good; it was during this run that Omega Red was introduced, one of my favorite X-Men villains. Of course, then Lee branched off and founded Image Comics, a venture that met with a certain amount of success, although most of the Image number 1’s that came from that period (Savage Dragon, Pitt, Pact, Shaman’s Tears, Cyber Force, Shadowhawk, and Lee’s own Wildcats and Deathblow, are now virtually worthless). More recently, Lee hopped over to D.C. comics, to do a one year run on Batman, the very fine Hush storyline which I think is one of the better Batman stories of recent years, though, to be fair, I’m not a huge Batman or D.C. fan in general, so I haven’t kept up with many recent exploits of the Caped Crusader. Jim Lee is one of those artists, though, that I’m a fan of to the point that I’ll buy any comic he’s drawn, or even drawn the cover of. To me, he’s the epitome of what comic art should be, at least superhero comic art. And it it’s wrong to get aroused from a Jim Lee drawing of Psylocke, then I don’t want to be right.
Next up is Barry Windsor-Smith, who I first became aware of during his serialized run of the Weapon-X storyline in Marvel Comics Presents in 1991. I was obsessed with the Wolverine character, and this glimpse into his past was of interest to me, particularly when told with an artistic style that was unlike any I had seen in comics before. If the cleanliness of Jim Lee’s style appealed to me, it was the abundance of detail in Windsor-Smith’s work that made me a fan. Each panel was so packed with it that I remember spending hours going back over each issue, poring over every page. Windsor-Smith contributed to several Valiant comics, including X-O Manowar, Archer and Armstrong, and Ninjak, but I never tracked most of those down; I was never much into Valiant. I did, however, unearth several of Windsor-Smith’s Conan the Barbarian comics that he drew for Marvel in the early 70’s, and those are also very fine. With an atypical style for the comic book medium that features a gritty, stylized violence, along with the abundance of detail I already mentioned, Barry Windsor-Smith has secured a spot among my top favorites.
Next is Steve Dillon, who I became a fan of in the 90’s when I first started collecting Preacher, the comic he co-created along with writer Garth Ennis. This was not the first pairing of the two, only the first one that I’d encountered; they also worked together on the series John Constantine: Hellblazer, which was later made into the decidedly sub-par movie Constantine. I collected the entire Preacher series, and consider it to be, along with Sandman, one of the best comics to come out in the 90’s. Dillon’s characters look less like superheroes and more like normal people, which is to say, they are more realistically proportioned, and he has a talent for facial expression that I would consider pretty much unparalleled among comics I’ve read. His art leaves a lasting impression, particularly his single panel splash shots. Recently, he’s done work for Marvel, drawing some issues of the relaunched Punisher series, the success of which led to a new Punisher movie staring Thomas Jaine a few years ago, though, like Constantine, it sucked. Of course, that wasn’t Steve Dillon’s fault. He’s also done work in the past couple of years for Wolverine: Origins, and, much like Jim Lee, his artwork put him on the short list of artists whose comics I will seek out and buy regardless of what they’re about and who’s writing them…a rare distinction. I was a little apprehensive about Dillon doing mainstream superhero mags, since his style, as I said, seemed to lend itself more to “ordinary” people, and Dillon being a comic book artist, I’m using that term extremely loosely, but he’s handled himself admirably.
Next is Todd McFarlane, another Marvel mainstay with an immediately recognizable style that I find very visually appealing. McFarlane came to prominence in the late 80’s during his run on Amazing Spiderman, that he took over as of issue 298. The next twenty-eight issues are some of the best Spiderman comics I’ve ever seen, both in terms of story and art, and they catapulted McFarlane to the forefront of the comic book universe. During this run he helped create Venom, one of Spiderman’s best loved and most enduring villains. Eventually, McFarlane became restless, wanting to write and illustrate his own stories, and Marvel allowed him to be the artist on the new series titled simply Spiderman; like Jim Lee with X-Men, the first few issues were a huge commercial success. However, a little more than a year later, McFarlane left Marvel, to form Image comics along with Jim Lee and others. There, he launched Spawn, arguably the most successful and enduring of all the Image comics. A movie has been made from that as well, in addition to a very popular series of toys. McFarlane is yet another artist whose work I’ll buy regardless of what he’s drawing, but unfortunately, he doesn’t illustrate much these days; he doesn’t have to. Spawn and all the toys and merchandise has made him boatloads of money, and he’s gotten bigger than the comic book industry. I don’t blame him for getting out. I probably would have too.
Last but not least is Jeff Smith, an artist who I only got into recently, but have quickly become a big fan of. Smith is best known for his finite series Bone, which ran from ‘91 through ‘04, and won several Eisner Awards. Bone is a brilliant and funny series, a blend of Tolkien style adventure with Walt Kelly’s Pogo, sprinkled with dashes of mysticism and spiritual and religious implication. The Bone cousins that serve as the focal point of the stories’ action look a bit like Casper the Friendly Ghost with legs, but the backdrop against which they are thrust seems more like Feudal England in the fourteenth century. It’s an interesting contrast, and Bone is a fun read. Smith beats out some other longstanding mainstays of mine, and is one of my pleasurable discoveries of recent years.
Among those who should receive honorable mention are Eric Larson, who had a memorable run on Amazing Spiderman before jumping ship to form Image and launch his ongoing series The Savage Dragon, Adam and Andy Kubert, who have done a variety of projects, mostly for Marvel, including X-Men, Wolverine, and Marvel 1602, and Rob Liefield, who I first got into during his run on New Mutants and X-Force for Marvel; he too split and helped found Image, where his solo project was Youngblood, a series with great art but little story to speak of. There are a good many more who I’ve followed over the years, but these are the ones that come most readily to mind. In the near future I plan on pitching the comic I’ve been writing along with my artist friend Jesse Renfrew to Image comics, so stay tuned on that. When Image responds, I will likely put up a post about it. Till then I’ll keep my fingers crossed, and in the meantime, I highly recommend seeking out any of the comics I mentioned in this blog. More soon.